Intolerance! A Silent Epic That Explores Humanity Through the Ages
“Intolerance,” directed by the legendary D.W. Griffith, isn’t just a film; it’s an experience. Released in 1916, this silent masterpiece takes viewers on a whirlwind journey through history, exploring the theme of intolerance across four distinct eras: ancient Babylon, the crucifixion of Christ, the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre in sixteenth-century France, and the persecution of Huguenots during the French Revolution.
Griffith, known for his groundbreaking techniques and cinematic innovations, uses parallel narratives to weave a tapestry of human experience, showcasing the recurring theme of intolerance through dramatic conflicts and poignant tragedies. While criticized for its historical inaccuracies and problematic portrayals of certain groups, “Intolerance” remains a powerful and thought-provoking film that continues to spark debate and discussion.
A Kaleidoscope of Historical Eras
The brilliance of “Intolerance” lies in its ambitious scope. Griffith masterfully interweaves four seemingly disparate stories, each representing a different period and cultural context:
-
Babylon: A tale of forbidden love between the Princess and the commoner Belshazzar, set against the backdrop of Babylonian opulence and ancient religious conflicts.
-
Judea: The story of Jesus Christ and his followers, culminating in the dramatic crucifixion scene. Griffith’s portrayal emphasizes the emotional impact of the event rather than strict biblical accuracy.
-
France (1572): The St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre, a horrific historical event where thousands of Huguenots (French Protestants) were slaughtered by Catholic extremists.
-
France (18th Century): The story of a modern-day love triangle entangled in the turmoil of the French Revolution, mirroring the themes of injustice and persecution present in the other narratives.
A Visual Feast and Technical Marvel
Griffith’s mastery of cinematic language is evident throughout “Intolerance.” He employs innovative techniques like close-ups, cross-cutting, and elaborate set designs to create a visually stunning and emotionally engaging experience. The film’s scale is breathtaking: massive battle scenes, intricate religious ceremonies, and intimate moments captured with startling realism.
Here are some notable technical aspects of “Intolerance”:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Set Design | Elaborate sets recreated ancient Babylon, biblical Jerusalem, and 16th-century France with stunning detail. |
| Cinematography | Innovative camera angles and movement techniques heighten the dramatic impact of each scene. |
| Editing | Griffith’s pioneering use of cross-cutting allowed him to weave together seemingly unrelated stories, creating a sense of interconnectedness and thematic unity. |
A Cast of Thousands
“Intolerance” boasted a massive cast of over 3000 extras, many of whom were recruited from local communities. While individual actors are not prominently credited in this silent era film, the sheer scale of the performance is remarkable. Griffith’s direction and meticulous attention to detail ensured that each performer contributed to the overall grandeur of the film.
A Legacy of Controversy and Acclaim
“Intolerance,” despite its technical brilliance and ambition, remains a controversial film due to its historical inaccuracies and stereotypical depictions of certain groups. Critics have pointed out Griffith’s romanticized portrayal of the Ku Klux Klan in his earlier film “The Birth of a Nation” (1915) and argued that some elements of “Intolerance” perpetuate similar harmful stereotypes.
Despite the controversy, “Intolerance” is recognized as a groundbreaking cinematic achievement. Its innovative storytelling techniques, ambitious scope, and powerful emotional resonance continue to inspire filmmakers today. The film serves as a reminder of both the immense creative potential of cinema and the need for critical engagement with historical representations on screen.
“Intolerance,” while flawed in some respects, remains a testament to D.W. Griffith’s vision and artistry. It is a cinematic experience that invites viewers to grapple with complex themes, contemplate the human condition, and marvel at the enduring power of storytelling.